a. Time is spent just to understand the problem.
b. Clarifying questions are asked.
c. Students are given significant time to ponder.
d. Students are encouraged to work with partners.
e. Conversation is important. Bouncing around ideas is important.
f. Students are given several days to keep thinking and trying.
g. Class time is spent to suggest a variety of approaches and different ways of thinking.
h. Finally, only after many groups have shared their thinking, answers are revealed.
By this point, most students have begun to understand the mathematical ideas that hold the key to each problem. For many students, lightbulbs will have flashed on. The logic of the final answer will be readily apparent. When all goes well, it is the students themselves who reveal the final correct answer.
See if you can solve these Thunder and Lightning problems. By all means, discuss them with your children if you haven't already.
![]() |
| From More Thought Provokers, Doug Rohrer and Joe Spooner |

