Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Issues in Standardized Testing


This post is an invitation to our next Conversation With Parents, with a mathematics theme.  Please consider this invitation, and RSVP to tell us you are coming.  If you are looking for the most recent I Love Math problems, please look at the  following two posts.  Thanks for visiting.

Conversation With Parents
The Next in the Series -- February 28, 7pm
This Conversation will be around the topic:

"Malcolm Gladwell, TIMSS* and The New York Times"
*Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study

Do persistence and creativity matter in standardized testing?

Malcolm Gladwell, in his book Outliers, records some surprising observations regarding the U.S. performance in the quadrennial TIMSS testing.  He poses probing questions about what many regard as lagging U.S. test results.   His observations point to the need to build student persistence and creativity in order to raise U.S. performance.  A New York Times contributor, Edward Rothstein, raises precisely the same questions.  To make his point, Rothstein analyses a particularly challenging question from one of the TIMSS tests.  

On February 28, a group of Mustard Seed students and teachers will lead this Conversation With Parents.  They will summarize the points raised by Gladwell and Rothstein, and look at the TIMSS question analysed by Rothstein.  They will consider other challenging questions posed in standardized tests, and demonstrate some efforts underway to help children build persistence and creativity at different developmental stages.

We hope you will come.  So we can plan materials and seating, please RSVP here:   RSVP Feb. 28

This event is free.

The Final, Most Challenging Problem

This problem is the most challenging one of the year.  It was given to Sixth, Seventh and Eighth Graders last week.  They are working on it now, full of energy and enthusiasm.

This problem was the subject of an article in the New York Times a few years ago by Edward Rothstein.  The article discussed the performance of U.S. students on the TIMSS studies (the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Studies.)  He used this problem as an opportunity to ponder why the U.S. is often considered to lag in international math standings.

He argues that people often assume that U.S. students are not mastering adequately high levels of math skills.  This "Fine Thread" problem illustrates that the issue may lie elsewhere.  This problem requires only Middle School level mathematics skills, but appears to be much more difficult that that.  The challenge for the student is to "see" the problem in more than one way.  This problem rewards a student who persists and brings creativity to the process.

This problem appeared in the first TIMSS exam in 1995-96, and was the one on which students worldwide performed the worst!  We can't wait to see how Mustard Seed students do with it.





More Problems For Fourth and Fifth Grades!

The Fourth and Fifth Grade students are showing lots of energy and initiative as they work on their I Love Math problems.  Here are the most recent ones handed out.  Please feel free to work on these, and send answers and questions to Mr. Lawrence.  Most important, please discuss these problems with your children!

These problem comes from Thought Provokers by Doug Rohrer and Joe Spooner, 1993, Key Curriculum Press.