Sunday, January 28, 2018

The Lightbulb Problem -- On or Off?

As you can see from the prior two posts, students are already highly engaged in solving some difficult problems.  They display remarkable persistence and creativity.  (If you haven't already, please look at the prior post for some beautiful student work.)

Here is the problem they are working on now.  This was a favorite of students in past years, so we have brought it back for 2018.  If you have a child in Grades 6 - 8, please discuss it with them.  You will be surprised by their ability to spot patterns, and by their insights:

This problem comes from More Thought Provokers by Doug Rohrer and Joe Spooner, Key Curriculum Press, 1994.

Some Spectacular Student Work!

After students work out the solution to a challenging I Love Math problem, they still have a lot of work to do.  We ask student teams to turn in "submissions" to explain their thinking and convince an audience that their answer is correct.


It is in this submission process that some of the best mathematics lies.  It requires teams to consider the mathematical "key" to solving the problem, and the best way to communicate it to an audience.  It also requires the team to draw on all the creative talents of its members.

The graphic above might just look like a beautiful, colorful design.  However, it is actually the final image in a tremendously fun and creative submission to the How Many Squares? problem (see prior post).  This link takes 85 seconds, and is worth every second.  Enjoy!

How Many Squares? Submission by a 7th Grade Team

Of course, this counting program only answered the first half of the How Many Squares? challenge.  The second part required students to determine the area of each of the 50 squares.  An 8th grade team found a very creative way to use the pythagorean theorem to calculate the areas of the tilted squares.  They submitted a complete slide show, and included this as their final slide:


For students that were not familiar with the pythagorean theorem, there was a more intuitive way to calculate the areas of tilted squares.  Here is how another Eighth Grade team described it:



You might be interested in the solution to the second problem in the prior post, Le Havre to New York.  An Eighth Grade team turned in a beautiful solution using only two slides:





To see more great student work, keep visiting the blog in the coming weeks.  And visit Mustard Seed School on February 15 -- I Love Math Day!


Monday, January 15, 2018

I Love Math Season 2018

I Love Math season has begun again.  Already students are working on two challenging problems, the first of four they will do to prepare for I Love Math day. I Love Math day will be celebrated on Thursday, February 15.  (This is because February 14 is Ash Wednesday, so our mathematics celebration will be delayed by one day.)

Here is the first problem:



Here is the second:


We hope that students will discuss these problems with parents and friends.  They are meant to be enjoyed, and every problem will contain interesting mathematical insights appropriate for middle school students.

What are the rules?  Students may do anything a mathematician would do!
Ask a parent for help?  Of course!
Ask an expert?  Would a mathematician do that?  Of course!
Research on the internet?  Yes!

The one thing a mathematician would never do is present some else's work as their own.  Each team, and each student, must "own" the work they turn in.  They are expected to explain and articulate the ideas in their submissions. 

Come back soon for the next problems!