Tuesday, February 5, 2013

The Final, Most Challenging Problem

This problem is the most challenging one of the year.  It was given to Sixth, Seventh and Eighth Graders last week.  They are working on it now, full of energy and enthusiasm.

This problem was the subject of an article in the New York Times a few years ago by Edward Rothstein.  The article discussed the performance of U.S. students on the TIMSS studies (the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Studies.)  He used this problem as an opportunity to ponder why the U.S. is often considered to lag in international math standings.

He argues that people often assume that U.S. students are not mastering adequately high levels of math skills.  This "Fine Thread" problem illustrates that the issue may lie elsewhere.  This problem requires only Middle School level mathematics skills, but appears to be much more difficult that that.  The challenge for the student is to "see" the problem in more than one way.  This problem rewards a student who persists and brings creativity to the process.

This problem appeared in the first TIMSS exam in 1995-96, and was the one on which students worldwide performed the worst!  We can't wait to see how Mustard Seed students do with it.